NewsMontana Politics

AG Knudsen won't defend Montana political spending in federal court

Austin Knudsen
Add KXLF as a Google Preferred Source

HELENA — As legal challenges to Montana’s newly approved ballot initiative on corporate political spending move forward, the state’s top attorney says his office won’t defend the measure.

Attorney General Austin Knudsen made the announcement in a document filed Friday in federal court.

“The Attorney General has determined that Initiative 194 plainly violates the First Amendment under the U.S. Supreme Court’s decisions in First Nat’l Bank v. Bellotti and Citizens United v. Fed. Election Comm’n,” the document says. “This is consistent with the Attorney General’s prior legal position when evaluating similar proposals that restrict the political speech for entities with corporate charters.”

However, Knudsen said he would enforce I-194, “until the judicial branch can render a decision in this matter.”

I-194, also called “the Montana Plan” was specifically intended as a challenge to the 2010 Citizens United decision. Supporters have argued states have the authority to define the powers of “artificial persons” like corporations, unions and nonprofits, so it seeks to revise those powers and simply exclude the power to spend money in elections.

I-194 passed with about 66% of the vote – more than 307,000 votes in favor – in this month’s elections.

In a statement on social media, the Transparent Election Initiative – the group that introduced I-194 – said it would step in to defend the law.

"Two-thirds of Montanans voted to end corporate and dark money spending in our elections,” said TEI founder and president Jeff Mangan. “But the Attorney General has decided that the will of the people – the voices of real Montanans – simply doesn't matter. We won't stand for it.”

Last week, a group of plaintiffs including the Montana Chamber of Commerce, the Billings and Kalispell Chambers of Commerce and the U.S. Chamber of Commerce filed another federal lawsuit against the measure. It followed an earlier challenge from the Frontier Institute, the Montana Republican Party and the Montana Family Foundation.

The business groups argued I-194 is already having “immediate and severe chilling effects” on their – and their members’ – abilities to engage in political speech and plan for upcoming election cycles. They described it as “targeted speech suppression” against businesses.

“Montana has no legitimate interest in suppressing political speech to equalize the relative voices of speakers,” the plaintiffs’ attorneys wrote.

The Frontier Institute challenge and the Chamber’s challenge have now been combined into a single case. As of Monday morning, no federal court hearings have been scheduled yet in the case.